COP31 climate negotiations are bigger than ever, with tens of thousands of participants, including government officials, scientists, activists, businesses, policymakers and environmental organisations, who had converged at the conference to discuss the future of the planet. However, few are there to agree on how decisively it should move away from fossil fuels challenge.
The paradox at the center of the conference is striking. The event has attracted a record number of lanyard-wearing participants, who stream in every morning, proceeding to pack every corridor of a gargantuan center, but only a relatively small proportion are involved in formal climate negotiations. The remaining attendees are engaged in advocacy, scientific discussions, technological demonstrations, business networking, climate initiatives and efforts to mobilise resources for environmental action.
The question that continues to haunt international climate diplomacy is whether this growing participation will translate into meaningful action. As behind the enormous crowds, climate exhibitions, networking events and ambitious declarations lies an uncomfortable reality: The world continues to struggle with fossil fuel phaseout – shocking’ signs of climate change.

COP31 and the Fossil Fuels Challenge: Why the World Still Hesitates
The annual United Nations climate conferences have transformed considerably over the decades. What once consisted largely of relatively small, technical meetings between government representatives has evolved into enormous international gatherings involving thousands of organisations and individuals.
COP31 has increasingly evolved beyond a traditional diplomatic gathering into a global climate marketplace of ideas, partnerships and solutions. A record number of people have attended the talks, which has become part trade show, part carnival, part climate therapy session. It has reportedly attracted around 92,000 registered participants, making it one of the largest climate conferences in the history of the UN process.
The gathering is not only about negotiating agreements between governments. It has become a platform for environmental campaigns, technological innovation, investment opportunities, climate education and the exchange of ideas. At the heart of debate is fossil fuel phaseout – one of the most consequential yet politically contentious challenges confronting the world.
Scientists presented tools to identify methane emissions. Environmental filmmakers highlighted pollution and waste. Renewable-energy advocates sought financial support for solar projects. Businesses showcased technologies designed to reduce emissions, while activists urged governments to confront fossil fuel dependence.
These diverse activities reflected the growing recognition that climate action cannot be achieved through government negotiations alone. Communities, businesses, researchers, investors and civil society have important roles in reshaping the global economy.
However, the expanding scale of COP conferences has also generated criticism. Their growing carbon footprint, logistical complexity and enormous financial costs have prompted some environmental leaders to question whether the gatherings have become too large. Nevertheless, supporters argue that the conferences provide a unique opportunity to connect people working towards a common goal. Even when formal agreements remain limited, partnerships and initiatives emerging on sidelines contribute to practical environmental progress. The challenge is ensuring that these activities do not become a substitute for political decisions required to address the underlying causes of climate change.

The fossil fuel dilemma: Acknowledging the crisis but avoiding its root cause
Climate change is increasingly visible in devastating floods, wildfires, prolonged droughts, extreme heat, melting glaciers and ecosystem disruption across the world. Yet, despite growing scientific warnings, the global energy system remains heavily dependent on coal, oil and natural gas.
According to the figures cited in climate discussions, fossil fuels account for approximately 68 per cent of global greenhouse gas emissions and nearly 90 per cent of carbon dioxide emissions. Their continued use is a major driver of global warming, making a transition towards cleaner energy systems indispensable for limiting future climate risks.
At COP31, the debate over fossil fuels has once again exposed divisions among nations. Oil- and gas-producing countries remain reluctant to endorse language that could threaten their economic interests, while many climate-vulnerable nations and environmental advocates are calling for a clearer roadmap towards a fossil fuel phaseout. Ultimately, the transition away from fossil fuels is not merely about changing the sources of energy. It is about reimagining our relationship with nature, reshaping our economies and ensuring that technological progress does not come at the expense of the planet that sustains us.
The world has the knowledge, technologies and resources to move towards a cleaner future. What remains urgently needed is the political courage, international solidarity and collective determination to turn that possibility into reality. European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen described the recent wave of extreme weather and devastating wildfires as a “summer of truth” while addressing world leaders in Antalya on November 11. She warned that the world was heading towards an overshoot of the 1.5°C warming threshold and emphasised that every fraction of a degree mattered.
Although she highlighted electrification, clean economies and international partnerships, she did not explicitly mention the need to phase out fossil fuels. This omission drew criticism from climate advocates who argued that electrification without a clear commitment to reducing fossil fuel dependence could leave the underlying energy system largely unchanged.
The criticism reflects a broader contradiction within international climate diplomacy. Governments increasingly acknowledge the urgency of climate action, but addressing the energy sources responsible for much of the warming remains politically difficult. The world can’t effectively tackle climate change without confronting the role of fossil fuels in electricity generation, transport, industry, agriculture and other economic activities.

Finland offers a practical example of moving beyond fossil fuels
While international negotiations continue to struggle with consensus, Finland has taken a significant step by publishing a domestic roadmap for transitioning away from fossil fuels. The initiative follows similar efforts by France, Germany and the Netherlands and reflects growing recognition that governments need practical strategies rather than broad climate declarations.
Finland already generates more than 96 per cent of its electricity from non-fossil sources, placing it among the world’s leading countries in clean electricity production. Nevertheless, its wider energy system remains challenging because of energy-intensive industries, long transport distances and substantial heating requirements during extremely cold winters.
In 2025, wood fuels accounted for approximately 28 pc of Finland’s total energy consumption, nuclear energy represented 27 per cent and fossil fuels around 18 per cent. The country aims to achieve carbon neutrality by 2035, although its new roadmap does not establish a legally binding deadline for completely phasing out fossil fuels.
Finland’s approach demonstrates that the energy transition involves more than expanding renewable electricity. It requires restructuring transportation, heating, industrial processes and other sectors that remain dependent on fossil fuels. National roadmaps can help governments identify obstacles, establish priorities, mobilise investment and gradually reduce dependence on carbon-intensive energy systems.

The Santa Marta coalition: A new direction for climate diplomacy
Frustrated by the slow pace of international negotiations, countries supporting a fossil fuel transition have increasingly begun pursuing cooperation outside the traditional UN framework. The Santa Marta initiative, launched in Colombia in April, brought representatives from 57 countries together to explore practical pathways for reducing dependence on coal, oil and gas.
Unlike formal UN negotiations, the process provides an opportunity for governments to exchange ideas, coordinate policies and develop national strategies without requiring every country to agree on a binding international commitment. However, the coalition has also encountered political challenges. Colombia, one of its founding members, has withdrawn following a change of government. The new administration of President Abelardo de la Espriella has promised to strengthen the country’s oil and gas industry, reversing the previous emphasis on reducing fossil fuel dependence.
Despite this setback, the initiative is moving forward. Ireland and the Pacific island nation of Tuvalu are preparing to assume leadership, with another international conference planned for July 2027. California Governor Gavin Newsom has also given the initiative significant political momentum. Speaking at COP31, he explicitly endorsed the global phaseout of fossil fuels and expressed support for the Santa Marta coalition.
His position is particularly noteworthy because California represents one of the world’s largest subnational economies, while the US federal administration continues to remain absent from the climate summit.
Germany has already committed to phasing out fossil fuels by 2045, while France and the Netherlands have developed their own transition roadmaps. Such initiatives indicate that climate cooperation can continue even when the traditional international negotiating process encounters political obstacles. The collective influence of countries and regions pursuing cleaner energy policies could also shape international markets, investment decisions and technological development.

Electrification: An opportunity to accelerate the clean energy transition
Another major discussion at COP31 concerns Türkiye’s 35-by-35 initiative, which aims to increase electricity’s share of global energy demand to 35 per cent by 2035, compared with approximately 23 per cent today. The idea is to accelerate electrification across sectors that traditionally rely on fossil fuels. Electric vehicles, heat pumps, electric cooking systems and industrial electrification can reduce emissions when powered by cleaner electricity.
However, electrification alone does not guarantee a cleaner environment. If electricity continues to come from coal-fired power plants and other carbon-intensive sources, the environmental benefits of electrifying transport, heating and industry will remain limited. Electrification must go hand in hand with clean electricity generation, energy efficiency, storage and responsible infrastructure development.
The proposed 35-by-35 goal could encourage countries to expand solar, wind, geothermal, hydropower and other low-carbon energy sources while modernising electricity grids. Energy storage will also be important. Batteries can help balance electricity supply and demand, store surplus renewable energy and provide greater flexibility when solar and wind generation fluctuate.
Nuclear energy is another option being discussed as part of the broader transition. Some policymakers argue that advanced nuclear technologies and small modular reactors could complement renewable energy by providing reliable electricity with low operational carbon emissions.
The transition, however, should not become a competition between technologies. A sustainable energy system will require a carefully balanced combination of renewable energy, storage, efficient grids, responsible technological development and low-carbon sources suited to national circumstances.
AI and data centres: The emerging energy challenge
The growing demand for artificial intelligence has introduced another complicated dimension to the energy transition. Data centres are expanding rapidly, consuming electricity and water while raising concerns about energy prices, infrastructure pressure and environmental impacts. Artificial intelligence could become either a contributor to growing environmental pressures or a useful tool for climate action, depending on how it is developed, powered and managed.
The United States, despite being absent from COP31, has considerable opportunities to shape the future of this industry. Policymakers could require or encourage data centre developers to use clean electricity, improve energy efficiency, recycle water, reduce noise pollution and choose sites that minimise environmental and community impacts. Such measures could help ensure that technological expansion does not undermine climate goals or place disproportionate burdens on local communities.
Artificial intelligence can also assist environmental monitoring, improve energy efficiency, identify methane leaks, support climate modelling and help manage electricity grids. These applications could make technology an important contributor to environmental protection.
But the benefits of AI cannot justify unlimited resource consumption. Its expansion must be accompanied by accountability, clean energy investment, water stewardship and responsible planning. The future of technological innovation and climate action should not be treated as opposing forces. With the right policies, both could contribute to a more sustainable economy.

Climate finance remains a major obstacle for developing countries
Moving away from fossil fuels is not simply a matter of political willingness. For developing economies, the transition involves enormous financial, technological and infrastructural challenges.
Türkiye’s Energy Minister Alparslan Bayraktar has argued that developing countries cannot abandon coal and other fossil fuels without access to affordable technology and sufficient financing. His argument highlights an important dimension of climate justice: countries with limited financial resources cannot be expected to transform their energy systems without meaningful international support.
At COP29 in Baku, developed countries agreed to mobilise at least $300 billion annually for developing nations by 2035, within a broader ambition of raising $1.3 trillion from public and private sources. COP30 also produced commitments to increase adaptation finance, but questions concerning funding baselines, responsibilities and delivery mechanisms remain unresolved.
A further concern is the widening gap between the financial resources available and the actual needs of vulnerable countries. A United Nations Environment Programme assessment published shortly before COP31 indicated that even tripling current international public adaptation finance would cover only around 23–29 per cent of developing countries’ requirements.
For countries such as Pakistan, which contribute relatively little to global greenhouse gas emissions but experience devastating floods, heatwaves, droughts and other climate-related disasters, the issue is particularly urgent. Pakistan faces the dual challenge of protecting its population from increasingly severe climate impacts while meeting its development, energy and infrastructure needs. Expanding renewable energy, strengthening electricity systems, improving energy efficiency and building climate-resilient infrastructure require substantial investment.
A fair energy transition must therefore combine ambitious emission reductions with accessible climate finance, technology transfer and greater support for vulnerable economies. Developing countries need opportunities to expand clean energy without compromising their development priorities or imposing unbearable costs on people.
Climate conferences must deliver more than declarations
COP31 illustrates both the growing global commitment to climate action and the frustration surrounding its pace. The enormous gathering reflects the seriousness with which governments, scientists, businesses and communities increasingly view climate change. Yet the size of the conference alone cannot measure its success.
The real test is whether discussions translate into policies, investment, technology and tangible reductions in greenhouse gas emissions. The world has made progress. Renewable energy has expanded, climate awareness has increased, and international cooperation has helped prevent some of the worst warming projections that were once anticipated. Nevertheless, current trajectories still point towards a dangerously warm future, and the gap between climate promises and implementation remains substantial.
The fossil fuels challenge is no longer simply an environmental aspiration. It is increasingly connected to economic resilience, public health, energy security, technological innovation and the protection of ecosystems. However, the transition must be fair, realistic and inclusive. Wealthier nations, which have historically contributed disproportionately to greenhouse gas emissions, must provide greater financial and technological support to developing countries. Governments must also ensure that energy transitions protect workers, communities and vulnerable populations.
The world cannot afford to turn climate conferences into annual celebrations of promises that remain unfulfilled. Every commitment must be accompanied by measurable progress, accountability and practical action. The future of our planet will not be determined by the number of delegates attending climate conferences, the grandeur of exhibition halls or the volume of declarations made from podiums. It will depend on choices governments, industries and societies make when they return home.
Ultimately, the transition away from fossil fuels is not merely about changing the sources of energy. It is about reimagining our relationship with nature, reshaping our economies and ensuring that technological progress does not come at the expense of the planet that sustains us. The world has the knowledge, technologies and resources to move towards a cleaner future. What remains urgently needed is the political courage, international solidarity and collective determination to turn that possibility into reality.